Identifying the Lost Suttons of Albemarle County, North Carolina, Part II

In Part I, I laid out the case that Samuel Sutton (c.1722-1764) of Perquimans County, North Carolina was an undocumented son of Nathaniel Sutton (1681-c.1743) by an unknown first wife. Samuel is one of four Sutton men of his generation who seem likely to be brothers. The other three are:

John Sutton (c.1702-aft.1741) appears in Bertie County 1723-1741, wife Mary;

James Sutton (c.1712-1770) married Anne Penrice (Perquimans, Granville & Bertie County 1753-1770);

Ephraim Sutton (c.1720-bef.1772) was a neighbor of James Sutton in Perquimans County.

There is further circumstantial evidence that these men are potentially brothers, and further evidence that James's descendants migrated west into what is now Rutherford County, North Carolina.

JOHN SUTTON (c.1702-aft.1741)

An unidentified John Sutton was the Clerk of Court in Bertie County, North Carolina from at least August 1723 and was a witness to about a third of the deed written over the next two decades. John was himself  recorded buying land in Bertie County in 1725, 1726 and 1739. A 1737 deed identifies his wife as Mary. 

Not much else is known about this John Sutton, who disappears from Bertie County after 1741. Given his status as a local clerk, it seems unlikely that he died around then with no mention in court records. It seems more likely that he simply moved away, though where to isn't clear.

He could be the John Sutton who appears in the records of Dobbs County, North Carolina in 1748 and died there in 1773. No wife was recorded, but he had three documented sons: Benjamin Sutton (born about 1752; died 1837); John Sutton, Jr. (born about 1758; died 1820-1830); and William Sutton (born about 1760; died 1813-1820). All three sons were born and lived in Bucklesberry, which is about 100 miles southwest of Perquimans County. 

There were four other possible sons living in the county as well: Thomas Sutton (born before 1758; death year unknown); James Sutton (born 1755-1767; death year unknown); Richard Sutton (born 1755-1773; died 1800-1810); and Simon Sutton (born 1765-1767; died before 1813). John likely had daughters, too, but no document evidence to date has emerged to identify their names.

Given the age difference between John Sutton of Bertie County and the children born to John Sutton of Dobbs, it is possible that John of Bertie was the father of John of Dobbs; or they may be unrelated. For further information on the Dobbs County John Sutton, see https://suttonancestry.com/john-sutton-first-in-bucklesberry/

JAMES SUTTON (c.1712-1770)

James was extensively documented in Perquimans County, beginning with a deed of 100 acres from Francis Penrice in April 1753.

The following year, James appears in tax list of Perquimans County, with just 1 tithable (himself). On this same list are Samuel Sutton (5), Joseph Sutton Esq., Joseph Sutton Jr. and Edward Penrice, indicating they lived in the same part of the county.

Sometime during that year, James seems to have moved to Granville County, North Carolina, being named along with a John Sutton in a muster roll of the Granville County militia in October 1754. The following year he appears in the Granville County tax rolls, again claiming only himself as tithable. James disappears from Granville County after 1755, but appears in Bertie County beginning in the tax census of 1757.

While these could be different men named James Sutton, the scarcity of the name in this Sutton clan suggest they are the same man. Also, Robert Allen appears with James Sutton in the Granville County 1755 tax census just 11 households away from Sutton. In the 1757 tax list of Bertie County, James Sutton shared a household with Robert Allen, indicating co-migration among these eastern counties.

James Sutton seems to appear in no further records until April 15, 1770, when his estate entered into probate in Perquimans County. Samuel Penrice, his brother-in-law, was administrator and a James Sutton was the only Sutton at his estate sale. This is his son. Evidently there was a will but it doesn't seem to have been recorded.

James Sutton Jr. appears in a 1771 deed clarifying some of the relationships in this family:

Oct. 21, 1771 - James Sutton to Benj Scarbrough - 15 pds for 30 acres - NW Yeopin Creek near bend of a swamp out of Franks Creek - sd land given by my grandfather Francis Penrice to my father James Sutton Sr and by his will to me. (Perquimans Co. NC deeds, Book H, #183)

And in a further deed he shows a relation to the late Ephraim Sutton, probable brother of James Sr.:

Feb. 6, 1772 - James Sutton to Joshua Skinner - 25 pds for 50 acres - NS Yeopim Creek adj to land belonging to orphans of Ephraim Sutton to a branch issuing out of Albemarle Sounty. Witnesses Samuel Penrice, Elizabeth Penrice. (Perquimans Co. NC deeds, Book H #198)

James Sutton and Ann Penrice (named daughter in the will of Francis Penrice of Perquimans County, in April 1756) had four likely sons who migrated into western North Carolina:

1. John Sutton (c.1734-1817), who appears in the Granville County militia rolls in 1754 and was noted "absent" in rolls of 1771. He appears in court in Granville County in 1755 and 1757. He is likely the same John Sutton who begins appearing in deeds in Anson County, North Carolina in 1768 and evidently married Eleanor Ashley, daughter of John Ashley of Anson County, who names a daughter "Elianer Sutton" in his 1759 will. In 1772, John Sutton was a witness for John Ashley (Jr., son of above John Ashley) in a deed in Tryon County, North Carolina; by 1779, he had been granted 50 acres on Floyd's Creek in Rutherford County, North Carolina, where he would remain the rest of his life. He sealed his will in March 1814 naming children Elizabeth Sutton, Robert Sutton, William Sutton, John Sutton, Sarah Sutton and James Sutton, among other legatees. His will was recorded July 6, 1817.

2. James Sutton (1751-aft.1834), a Revolutionary War veteran who self-reported being born in Granville County, North Carolina in April 1751 in his veteran's pension application. In 1771-1772, he sold off his father's property and (by his own account) removed to Halifax County, North Carolina where he lived until 1780, though contemporary records actually place him back in Granville County during this period, serving under Capt. William Gill during the Revolutionary War. James reported living in Rutherford County, North Carolina from 1780 to 1805, when he finally settled in Lincoln County, North Carolina. He reported being poor and illiterate and evidently wrote no will. No wife is known, but he seems to be father to James Sutton, William Sutton, Colby Sutton and others who later migrated from Rutherford County, North Carolina to Smith County, Tennessee. Colby was named legatee in the will of the above John Sutton.

3. Samuel Sutton (1750s-aft.1800), about whom little is known. In 1788 he appears with John Sutton in a suit against James Kincaid in Lincoln County, North Carolina. Samuel, who was likely named for Samuel Sutton (d.1764) of Perquimans County, North Carolina, appears in census records of Lincoln County through 1800. He may be the father of William and James Sutton who appear in Lincoln County marriage bonds in 1818 and 1832, respectively.

4. Dempsey Sutton (bef.1765-aft.1820), another brother about whom little is known. He does appear to have initially migrated with the other Suttons to Lincoln County, North Carolina where he appears as "Densy Sutton" in a suit by the state of North Carolina in January 1788. After being found guilty, he seems to have returned to Granville County where he was sold property near Low Ground Creek by David Blalock in 1801. He last appears in the 1820 census of Granville County. No name found for his wife. He may be the father of Edward Sutton, a War of 1812 veteran who also appears in Granville County in the 1820 census.

EPHRAIM SUTTON (c.1720-c.1772)

Ephraim Sutton is only mentioned in three deeds between 1757 and 1772, the earliest of these confirming he was more likely to be a brother than a son of James Sutton (c.1712-1770). In February 1757, Ephraim bought 100 acres in Perquimans County on Franks Creek, "adjacent James Sutton." In a final deed of October 1772 the "orphans of Ephraim Sutton" were mentioned, but there appears to be no record of their names. It is possible he is the father or grandfather of another Ephraim Sutton (1768-1819) who genealogists believe was from Chowan County, North Carolina.

Research and documentation by Jason M. Farrell

DAR Ancestor A111309 Confuses THREE Separate Men Named James Sutton

 

An entry in the Daughters of the American Revolution patriot index gives the following information for DAR Patriot Ancestor #A111309:

SUTTON, JAMES
Service: NORTH CAROLINA    
Rank(s): SECOND LIEUTENANT
Birth: 1747 GUILFORD CO NORTH CAROLINA
Death: 1815 SMITH CO TENNESSEE
Service Description: 1) 2ND REGT

The entry also names his wife as "Martha Elizabeth Brown" and lists children named Dempsey Sutton and James Sutton whom descendants have joined the DAR through. It's important to note that this is not the James Sutton of Lincoln County, North Carolina (1834) who served as a drummer in the 5th regiment in Halifax County, North Carolina c.1780. More on him later.

There was indeed a James Sutton who served in the 2nd North Carolina regiment which was mustered in 1775 in Salisbury, Edenton and New Bern, North Carolina. Salisbury is northeast of Charlotte, while the other two cities are on the eastern shoreline. This James Sutton received a pay voucher for his service in Edenton dated July 24, 1784 and appears in the records of Chowan County (in which Edenton sits) from 1785 until his death in 1826. Without a doubt, he did not die in Tennessee in 1815 as the DAR entry suggests.

So where did this DAR information come from?

Looking at Smith County, Tennessee records, there doesn't seem to be any evidence of a James Sutton who died in 1815; there is however one who died in 1835. This James Sutton was from North Carolina and first patented land in Smith County, Tennessee on April 27, 1814. He bought more land in 1817, 1818, 1827 and 1830. The 1814 patent was actually awarded to Joseph Randolph for military service in 1797, but Randolph declared James Sutton "assignee."

This James Sutton sealed his will on January 6, 1835, naming wife Alsey Sutton and children George Sutton, Edmund Sutton, James Sutton, Dempsey Sutton and Milly Williams. Note that the name Dempsey among his children is consistent with DAR records, so this appears to be the James Sutton the DAR is referring to.

Some more light is shed on this James Sutton by a family legend as told in a letter in 1940, transcribed below.

Transcribed By Vada Sutton

March 9, 1950
 
The Sutton Family

Below is a letter we write to Mrs. H. A. Russell, wife of Elder Henry A. Russell, of Murfreesboro, Tennessee, about ten years ago.  Since it is already written and as time is limited, we are taking the liberty of publishing it as it was written, for the benefit of others who might be interested in the history of the family, even though there are several personal matters contained in the letter, which is as follows:

Lafayette, Tenn., Aug. 3, 1940

Mrs. H. A. Russell

Murfreesboro, Tenn.

Dear Mrs. Russell:

At last I have found that record I made from information given me by your late father James M. Sutton, relative to the history of his family.  I put down what he told me largely in the form of a diagram and from it, I will give you most of the information I received from him.  If any part of it is not plain, please write me and I will do my best to make it all clear.  He told me that the first James Sutton of whom he had any knowledge was a native of Wales, coming to North Carolina about 1650.  Four brothers, names unknown, came with him.  

This James Sutton had a son, named James, a grandson bearing the same name, a great-grandson named James and a great-great-grandson, James, all in a direct line of descent from the first James Sutton.  With this great-great-grandson the record becomes a little more detailed.  

The great-great-grandson, born in 1736, was a second Lieutenant in the Revolutionary War, married Elizabeth Brown, weighed 550 pounds when last weighed and died on Defeated Creek in Smith County in 1836.  Three of his brothers are mentioned, although the name of one of them is unknown.  He left Tennessee for Scottsville, later moving to Indiana where one of his sons became Governor of that State. Another brother, Will Sutton, settled in Putnam County, Tennessee. The fourth brother, John Sutton, had two children, George Sutton and Ann, who married a Cooper.  

This is the entire record I have of the family up to this point except the family record of the large man, James Sutton, whose date of birth was in 1736.  He married Elizabeth Brown, and the record shows that he was twice married; but the name of the other wife is not given, nor is the order of his marriage.  However, the children of his first marriage appear to have been: Colby, George, Abner, Logan Jonathan, Joel and Oneida.  His children by the second marriage were: Edmund Sutton, James Sutton, Demps Sutton, Mellie and Nellie Sutton.

I have nothing as to the wives or husbands of any of the children of the first marriage except George Sutton, who married a Cartwright, an aunt of Clark Cartwright, a Confederate soldier who died on the head of Defeated Creek about 25 years ago.  George went to Dade County, Georgia, where he died as a very old man in 1878.  He had one son, Leroy Sutton, who married an aunt of Judge Sam Young, for many years a prominent citizen of Dixon Springs.  Leroy's children were, Howard Sutton, a Christian Preacher; James Sutton, another son whose name is believed to have been Will, and a daughter, Harriet.

Logan Sutton never married, but was a bachelor farmer on Peyton's Creek, owning six slaves and 1,000 acres of land.  He left home with a drove of horses and was never heard from again.  Colby is the only one whose descendants were given to me by your father.  He had two children.  Wilkerson and Bernettie Sutton.  Wilkerson married Barbara Wix, and Bernettie married the father of Aunt Bide Russell.  Wilkerson's children were: James, married a daughter of Levi Shoulder; David Colby Sutton, married Celia J. Austin; Jane Sutton, married Sherd Bailey; Mary Sutton, married Sam Shoulders; and one daughter whose name I do not have.  The offspring of James Sutton and the Shoulders woman, if any, is unknown to me.  David Colby and Celia J. Austin were the parents of Christian, Sallie, Eveline, James D., Clark, Philander and Cora Sutton.   Jane became the mother of two sons, Joe and Thomas Bailey.  Mary became the mother of one son, Matthew Shoulders.

***

There is a second source, possibly written around the same time, as follows:

The fifth family to settle on Defeated Creek was that of James Sutton, who was a soldier of the Revolution. He was a very large man, his vest being large enough to button around two average sized men. We have seen the big vest and know about its size from our own observation. He settled on a tract of land now a part of the old Lon Knight farm, and built a house toward the creek from the present Knight home. James moved to Smith County Tennessee with much of his family probably between 1800 and 1811. He settled on Defeated Creek. Defeated Creek was named after a battle where Indian Warrior, Hanging Maw, attacked and defeated a survey party in 1786. We are not sure how the town of Difficult was named.

***

Given that it names him as father of several of the children who appear in his 1835 will, the above letter appears to refer to the documented James Sutton of Smith County who died in 1835, a supposed Revolutionary War veteran. However, census records indicate he could not have fought in the Revolution. In the 1830 US Census of Smith County, Tennessee, James Sutton is listed as age 60-69 (b.1770s), as is his wife. Since the 1820 census shows he was born before 1775, we can place his birth between 1770 and 1775. He was not born in 1747 as the DAR states, nor was he 100 years old as family lore stated, and several of the older children attributed to him in the above letter are probably not his. Since his son George (named in his will) was born in 1790 per both family tradition and census accounts, James Sutton was likely born right around 1770.

This makes him too young to be the father of Colby Sutton, who was married in 1805 in Rutherford County, North Carolina (with James Sutton as bondsman, per county marriage bonds) before moving to Smith County, Tennessee. And of course, it makes him far too young to have fought in the Revolutionary War, calling his "patriot ancestor" status into question.

The evidence suggests that the above family lore confused James Sutton of Tennessee (c.1770-1835) with his likely father, James Sutton (1751-aft.1834) of Lincoln County, North Carolina.

This senior James Sutton evidently served in the Revolution, and gave an affidavit to that end as an 83-year-old man living in Lincoln County, North Carolina in 1834. This may be where the lore about James Sutton in the Revolution came from in the above letter.

In his Revolutionary War pension application, James Sutton of Lincoln County, North Carolina gave his birth as occurring in April 1751 in Granville County, North Carolina. He self-reported living in Halifax County, North Carolina from before 1776 to 1780 and Rutherford County, North Carolina from 1780 to 1805, when he finally settled in Lincoln County.

He testified that between 1778 and 1780 he served in the Granville County regiment under Capt. William Gill. Evidently, there was indeed a James Sutton who appears in Capt. Gill's muster during this period, but he was listed as a deserter shortly after his service began; James claimed he did not desert but was taken prisoner by loyalists. Regardless, the government was unimpressed by his application and he was not approved for a pension.

The crucial link between James Sutton of Lincoln County, North Carolina and the one in Smith County, Tennessee is Colby Sutton (c.1785-c.1838), who is likely son of the former and brother of the latter, given that he married in Rutherford County in 1805, which is where the senior James Sutton lived at the time, and later appears in the 1820 and 1830 US census in Smith County, Tennessee. Colby also appears with Abner Sutton (1770s-1848) in the 1820 US census of Smith County, who is likewise named as a son of James Sutton "by his first marriage" in the above family letter.

The DAR seems to have accepted flawed information that genealogists sourced from this letter of 1940, naming a Revolutionary War ancestor James Sutton with wife Elizabeth Brown (having evolved into Martha Elizabeth Brown by the time the DAR application was made) and a son named Dempsey Sutton. We know the DAR record of his death (1815) is false because James Sutton named a son Dempsey in his will 20 years later, and there is no evidence of a second Dempsey Sutton in Tennessee (there was a Dempsey Sutton in Lincoln County, North Carolina, but he was a whole generation older). Rather than one 100-year-old, 550-pound beast of a man with two wives and two sets of children born over thirty or more years, the above family lore likely refers to father-and-son James Suttons from North Carolina.

It is clear that the Lt. James Sutton of the 2nd NC regiment is not the ancestor of the Smith County, Tennessee Suttons, although descendants may still qualify for the DAR given that they probably do still descend from a James Sutton who served during the war. In any case, they should take a second look at patriot ancestor A111309.

=JMF